Throughout late childhood and now early adulthood, I have struggled with comparison culture. I compare myself to others in positive ways, such as I feel I have this thing over someone else, or in negative ways, such as I feel they have this thing over me. This is very unhealthy because it is so extrospective rather than introspective. I am focusing on others rather than myself and what I individually bring to the table. I know and understand that comparison on some level is an innately human experience. We all compare ourselves to some degree…but when is it normal vs unhealthy. Also, since most of my post puberty years have been spent on social media, is this feeling I have towards comparing myself to others heightened due to social media or do most people my age, regardless of social media usage, feel these things? I often compare my body to other people’s bodies. I also find myself comparing what they are doing and the places they go to what I am doing. For example, if I see a picture online about people doing something fun at Middlebury, I will most likely feel jealous if I am sitting in my room and uninvolved. However, are my struggles with comparison culture because of the pictures and videos I see on social media, or can it ultimately come from people I see face to face, and compare myself to them? I have found myself as I’ve gotten older wanting to put an end to this comparison between myself and others because it makes me feel bad about myself, even if I feel like I have something over someone else. The only time I have noticed comparison culture makes me feel good about myself is when I see someone online posting about a healthy recipe or a good workout, because then I feel inspired. I have been wanting to understand this question of comparison culture on social media vs in person and therefore solutions to both help myself but also help others who find themselves struggling as well. Through these thoughts and these little questions I have been posing, I want to raise the bigger question and seek to answer this question throughout the paper: how is comparison culture different on social media versus in person – and can comparison on social media motivate self-improvement or trap us in chronic dissatisfaction?
The first part of this question I want to answer is how is comparison culture different, if at all, for social media vs face to face interactions. If humans are innately creatures that compare themselves to others, and if comparison over social media and in person draw the same effects, then there should be little differences in well being across generations. However, a study done in 2023 says otherwise. An empirical test of social comparisons between 1990 and 2020 was conducted to see if social comparisons have in fact changed or gotten worse since the implementation of regular social media use in everyday life (Locke, 2023). For social comparisons, everything is the same for 1990 youth and 2020 youth, except for the increase in social media (Locke, 2023). And, the 2020 youth cohort reported substantially lower levels of self-esteem and higher levels of depressive symptoms compared to the 1990 youth cohort (Locke, 2023). This suggests that social media is having an effect on negative social comparisons more than in person comparisons. But why? Some researchers point to the prevalence of idealized and selectively edited images, which create more opportunities for upward comparison – situations where people feel their own attributes are inferior (Bonfanti et al., 2024). In real life, one may find themselves feeling less attractive than someone that they see on the street, but that feeling is usually fleeting. On social media, however, the exposure is repetitive and curated: idealized images of bodies, lifestyles, and success are constantly visible (Bonfanti et al., 2024). There is also a culture of editing images to make them even more unrealistic, and therefore unachievable (Bonfanti et al., 2024). In addition, in person, people are more authentic and have “bad days”. On Instagram, for example, no one is going to post an unflattering picture of themselves or an unhappy picture (McComb et al., 2023). It creates a cycle of unrealistic comparison targets that seem nearly impossible to live up to and seem too far away from one’s own reality. For these reasons, there is much more upward comparison than downward comparisons on social media (McComb et al., 2023). This imbalance enables comparisons over social media to be more long lasting and more detrimental than comparisons in person. Although both can be harmful in their own ways, social media comparisons and in person comparisons are in fact very different. This is part of the reason kids in our society today have reported a lower well being than kids in the 1990s.
The second question within my larger question about comparison culture is if social media can motivate self improvement stemming from that comparison. These upward comparisons that have been discussed can in fact be used to strive for self improvement (Caliskan, 2024). It stems from a social comparison theory in that individuals cannot assess their own abilities and opinions in pure isolation, but rather need the aspect of comparison for their own assessment (Caliskan, 2024). This theory asserts that within some individuals, there is a drive to improve when looking at pictures and/or videos on social media that they presume are better than them (Caliskan, 2024). This comparison through social media creates envy which in turn can fuel wanting to improve in a competitive sense (Caliskan, 2024). For some people, it becomes like a challenge that they want to live up to what they are seeing online and who they aspire to be (Ng et al., 2023). Some Instagram users have reported taking certain profiles as their personal role models, and therefore become more inspired to become better and more like their role models (Ng et al., 2023). In addition, studies have shown that some users emphasize the ability to see the good of others through this comparison (Ng et al., 2023). They feel gratitude, appreciation, and a sense that these people are deserving of whatever it is (Ng et al., 2023). This envy and admiration towards certain users and their respective posts on social media creates a desire to bridge the gap between the two of them (Ng et al., 2023). Social media users, specifically Instagram, feel if they put in some work and effort, they will be able to achieve the values they admire on their screen (Ng et al., 2023). However, although these can be seen as very positive outcomes for comparison culture, they do have some negative effects as well. If a user sees something online, such as a toned body, and decides to put in the work to appear like that, it may actually not be achievable for many reasons. One, every body is different and looks different even if the same work is put in. Two, that toned body could be an edited image, so it actually may not be possible to reach that. Although the initial intent was good to better oneself and work towards a goal, in the end it can create frustration and doubt (Ng et al., 2023). This can turn into a vicious cycle where a goal is set forth but it is never able to be reached. Also, the idea of competition and envy towards others is the same. It can get ugly and out of hand.
The third mini part of my big question is whether comparison culture from social media can leave people in chronic dissatisfaction. A lot of the research done has been regarding body dissatisfaction from social media, particularly fitness and toned idealized bodies. Fitspiration has been a new trend on TikTok that tries to inspire individuals to improve their health and fitness by showcasing diet and exercise videos (Pryde & Prichard, 2022). Although the intent may be good, and can try to get people inspired as discussed in the previous paragraph, its effects are far from beneficial. Fitspiration on TikTok has been associated with more weight dissatisfaction and an unhealthy need to be thin (Pryde & Prichard, 2022). Young caucasian men and women ranging from the UK, Australia, and North America report feeling inspired at first to be more fit, however, that feeling weans off because they then feel negatively towards their bodies because they are not achieving their fitness goals as soon as they like (Pryde & Prichard, 2022). They detailed that in the end it ended up being less healthy for them because they were undergoing extreme dieting, restrictive eating, and unrealistic comparisons to supermodel bodies (Pryde & Prichard, 2022). Yet again, these fit videos create chronic dissatisfaction because individuals feel they cannot live up to what they are seeing, because a lot of the time these videos online are edited and not entirely real (Pryde & Prichard, 2022). Another key part of dissatisfaction that has been studied in comparison culture within social media is a divide in wealth. Same as body comparisons, those with more wealth on social media are more readily available to be seen by everyone, even if their lifestyle is not the norm. A study was conducted in spring 2025 that concluded that when individuals see posts online about extravagant lifestyles, such as fancy vacations and fancy clothes, users felt more deprivation compared to seeing posts about natural scenery (Yan et al., 2025). This highlights that it is not purely just social media that is creating this chronic dissatisfaction, but the specific and curated posts that are dictating how people are feeling. These comparisons allow people to feel like they are not good enough and therefore end up upwardly comparing themselves to others. They perceive themselves less than in so many ways, as seen through body image and perception of lack of wealth.
This research is beneficial in starting to answer this complex question about comparison culture. For the most part, my research has answered the question as to why comparisons on social media are worse than natural comparisons in person. However, regarding self improvement and chronic dissatisfaction from comparisons on social media, the question is still not solidified. There are arguments to favor both aspects – some people are able to self improve because of social media while others are dissatisfied, and more are somewhere in between. It is hard to tell from a person where they will fall. Will they use social media comparisons as a way to fuel themselves to get better and work towards something that is important to them? Or will they sway in the opposite direction and become more and more dissatisfied and depressed with themselves because they either don’t look a certain way or don’t have certain things. The incomplete research raises the question of where the line is for bridging the gap between a user and a social media post/personality vs if there is no bridge because it is absolutely unachievable. How do people get to this point of wanting to get better for themselves without constantly needing to compare? Some solutions that come to mind during analyzing this question are: acceptance, acknowledgement, changing certain ways, and better offline connection. To break this down, I would say acceptance is the first part of a solution to unhealthy comparisons on social media. As mentioned, to some degree we all compare ourselves to others and need to accept that. This doesn’t mean we let it take over our lives, but instead, realize that we are insecure beings and will ultimately compare at some point. Next, acknowledgement that social media is making our comparisons worse because of how fake and prevalent they are. As a society, we have been doing better in realizing that social media is a highlight reel, but we need to keep reminding ourselves of that. Not everything you see on social media is true or factual and telling the full story…and that is vital to acknowledge. Next, changing certain ways with social media usage is key. We cannot get stuck in this endless cycle of social media and its detrimental impacts. A study was conducted to show that following body positive or appearance neutral Facebook pages has vastly improved body image in women (Fardouly et al., 2023). This would be a perfect solution if you find yourself in chronic dissatisfaction with your body. It is a way to change how you think because of what you allow yourself to see. Lastly, offline connection is so important in combatting these harmful social media comparisons. If you feel secure in yourself offline and feel like you have a good support system, these posts and videos will not make you feel as insecure and therefore not as likely to feel depressed or down about yourself. If people offline give you compliments and make you feel special, you are less likely to want to change things about yourself just because you see them online. Not only that, but it also stems from feeling good about yourself offline because then these posts will affect you less. Overall, we need to keep open communication about the damaging effects of social media, and especially its comparison culture. If we can use social media as a way to self improve all the time rather than feeling chronic dissatisfaction, that would be the ideal place to get to.
In this paper, I researched, learned, analyzed, and sought to answer solutions to comparison culture. I learned why comparison culture is so exaggerated for social media compared to in person interactions. Social media enables idealistic tendencies that can be viewed more often because of constant exposure. It is a highlight reel. On the other hand, in person, comparisons are not as extreme because they may be more realistic and more fleeting. I also learned about comparison culture and if it can lead to self improvement and/or chronic dissatisfaction through social media. This one is still a bit up in the air because people can lean towards either or both. There are some positive effects related to seeing images or videos on social media to then prompt self improvement goals. However, there are also negative effects from comparisons from social media regarding low self esteem and feeling worthless. The problem that arises from this is that people can have different reactions, so therefore there is not as much as a straightforward solution to fit every person. However, solutions such as acknowledgement and changing what you see on social media can prompt a more positive outlook on comparisons than a negative outlook. These solutions are in hopes that more people will utilize social media to better themselves for themselves, not to live up to how someone else looks or acts. I wonder if this is possible in a world that is being taken over by social media, especially for younger kids and generations that are growing up with this phenomenon.
References
Bonfanti, R.C., Melchiori, F., Teti, A., Albano, G., Raffard, S., Rodgers, R., Coco G. L. (2024). The association between social comparison in social media, body image concerns and eating disorder symptoms: A systematic review and meta-analysis. ScienceDirect. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bodyim.2024.101841
Caliskan, F., Idug, Y., Uvet, H., Gligor, N., & Kayaalp, A. (2024). Social comparison theory: A review and future directions. Psychology & Marketing, 41, 2823–2840. https://doi.org/10.1002/mar.22087
Fardouly J, Slater A, Parnell J, Diedrichs PC. Can following body positive or appearance neutral Facebook pages improve young women’s body image and mood? Testing novel social media micro-interventions. Body Image. 2023 Mar;44:136-147. doi: 10.1016/j.bodyim.2022.12.008. Epub 2023 Jan 4. PMID: 36608433.
Locke, K. D. (2025). Are there differences in the everyday social comparison experiences of youth in the 1990s versus 2020s? Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1080/23743603.2025.2507435
McComb, C. A., Vanman, E. J., & Tobin, S. J. (2023). A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Social Media Exposure to Upward Comparison Targets on Self-Evaluations and Emotions. Media Psychology, 26(5), 612–635. https://doi.org/10.1080/15213269.2023.2180647
Ng, J.C.K., Lin, E. S.S., Lee, V. K.Y. (2023). Does Instagram make you speak ill of others or improve yourself? A daily diary study on the moderating role of malicious and benign envy. ScienceDirect. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2023.107873
Piccoli, V., Carnaghi, A., Grassi, M., & Bianchi, M. (2022). The relationship between Instagram activity and female body concerns: The serial mediating role of appearance‐related comparisons and internalization of beauty norms. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 32(4), 728–743. https://doi.org/10.1002/casp.2586
Pryde, S., and Prichard, I. (2022). TikTok on the clock but the #fitspo don’t stop: The impact of TikTok fitspiration videos on women’s body image concerns. ScienceDirect. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bodyim.2022.09.004
Yan, Xiumei & Fu, Yu & Yang, Feng & Han, Yang. (2025). They shouldn’t be richer than me: How visual wealth exposure on social media increases relative deprivation. Cyberpsychology: Journal of Psychosocial Research on Cyberspace. 19. 10.5817/CP2025-2-4.